Failure to Warn: The Claim That Helped Win K.G.M.’s Case

When the Los Angeles jury ruled for K.G.M. on March 25, 2026, it found that Meta failed to adequately warn about the dangers of Instagram, along with being negligent in its design. As of November 2026 that finding has survived post-trial motions and is part of the judgment Meta is appealing.

Two claims left standing

K.G.M. did not reach trial with a long list of theories. In October 2023, Judge Carolyn Kuhl dismissed most claims in the coordinated cases, including product-liability design-defect claims, while letting negligence go forward, Bloomberg reported. By the time she denied the companies’ summary judgment motions on November 5, 2025, her order described the remaining causes of action as negligence and negligent failure to warn.

The two claims overlap but are not the same. Negligent design asks whether the product was built carelessly. Failure to warn asks something narrower: whether the company knew of a danger users would not see for themselves, and whether it did enough to tell them.

The questions jurors answered

The Meta verdict form, filed with the court on March 25, 2026 and published by Crowell & Moring, had seven questions. The first two addressed negligence. The remaining five set out the failure-to-warn claim step by step, and the jury checked “Yes” on each:

  • “Did Meta know or should it reasonably have known that the design or operation of Instagram was dangerous or was likely to be dangerous when used by a minor in a reasonably foreseeable manner?”
  • “Did Meta know or should it reasonably have known that users would not realize the danger?”
  • “Did Meta fail to adequately warn of the danger?”
  • “Would a reasonable platform designer or operator under the same or similar circumstances have warned of the danger or instructed on the safe use of the platform?”
  • “Was Meta’s failure to adequately warn or instruct a substantial factor in causing harm to K.G.M.?”

Each question is a separate element. Knowledge comes first, then whether the danger was hidden from users, then whether the warnings were inadequate, then what a reasonable designer would have done, and finally causation. A no on any one of them would have defeated the claim. YouTube had its own parallel form, and the jury found against it as well.

What the record said about warnings

Some of the most direct evidence was undisputed before trial. Kuhl’s November 5, 2025 order, a court record posted by Reason, recorded that K.G.M.’s mother learned of the dangers from a “60 Minutes” program and said she “would have never given K.G.M. a phone and things would be different.” It also recorded that neither K.G.M. nor her mother “ever saw any statements or warnings about the safety of Instagram.”

That testimony speaks to the last question on the form. A warning claim requires showing that a different warning would have changed what happened, and the mother’s account offered jurors a way to connect the missing warning to the harm.

Age limits on the witness stand

The question of who Instagram was warning, and whether its age rules worked, came up when Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg testified on February 18, 2026. According to NBC News, he acknowledged that some children lie about their age to use the services, said he did not see why the issue was so complicated, and said Meta has rules that people broadly understand. On safety tools, he said he always wished the company could have gotten there sooner.

Plaintiff lawyer Mark Lanier countered with a Meta review estimating more than 4 million users under 13 on Instagram in 2015, and reminded the jury that K.G.M. joined Instagram at 9. A week earlier, Instagram head Adam Mosseri had drawn a line between clinical addiction and what he called problematic use, meaning time on the app that people do not feel good about.

Ten of twelve

Because this was a civil case, nine of the 12 jurors had to agree on each question, and Judge Kuhl told them to treat each platform as a separate lawsuit. The liability vote was 10 to 2. Meta and Google then asked for a new trial, and Kuhl denied those motions in a ruling dated June 9, 2026. The full case history is in our main K.G.M. update.

Warnings ordered elsewhere

Warnings have since appeared in another court’s remedy. AP reported that the New Mexico judge’s order in that state’s child-safety case against Meta includes mandatory warnings, and the August 6, 2026 ruling requires safety banners for five years.

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy.