Progressive Total Loss Insurance Settlement: Who Can File a Claim?

You can file if you made a first-party claim on your Progressive personal-auto policy in Colorado and Progressive declared the vehicle a total loss. You must also fall inside the policy date window and have a Mitchell valuation with a projected sold adjustment. The case is Curran et al. v. Progressive Direct Insurance Co.

et al., No. 1:22-cv-00878 in the U.S. District Court for Colorado. It alleges Progressive underpaid total-loss claims using Mitchell valuations, as Justia records in the federal court decision entry. A total loss here means Progressive declared your vehicle a total loss and valued it for payment.

Table of Contents

Which Policies and Dates Count?

Eligibility starts with your own policy. You need a first-party claim on a personal-auto policy issued to a Colorado resident by Progressive Direct or Progressive Preferred. Value Pilot's overview of the court notice says Progressive must have declared the vehicle a total loss. Progressive Direct claims must have been submitted Apr.

12, 2019 through July 8, 2026. Progressive Preferred claims must have been submitted Dec. 19, 2021 through July 8, 2026. OpenClassActions lists both windows in its settlement timeline.

Why Does the Mitchell Report Decide Eligibility?

Your payment must rest on a Mitchell Instant Report. That report must have applied a projected sold adjustment to at least one comparable vehicle. ClassActionTracker notes that insurance or a total loss alone does not qualify.

Claims made against another driver's Progressive policy are excluded. You must have claimed under your own Colorado policy. Nylund's Collision Center review of the valuation dispute also notes Progressive denies liability and settled without admission.

What Payment Could You Receive?

Valid timely claim forms receive 68% of the projected-sold-adjustment impact. Value Pilot explains the math in its breakdown of the court notice, with impact set at 2.75% of recorded actual cash value for Direct and 2.25% for Preferred.

Value Pilot puts the total pool at about $15.24 million. For example, a $20,000 Direct cash value means a $550 impact and about $374 to the claimant.

How Do You File Before the Deadline?

No payment is automatic. You must file online at COTotalLossClaim.com or mail the signed postcard form. OpenClassActions says you need your Claimant ID or total-loss claim number plus the PIN from your notice. Online claims are due Feb. 5, 2027 at 11:59 p.m.

ET, and mailed forms must be postmarked that date. ClassActionTracker lists these cutoffs in its claim notice guide, with opt-outs and objections due Nov. 5, 2026 before a Jan. 6, 2027 fairness hearing. Final approval is still pending, so no payment date is set.

  • Get your Claimant ID or claim number plus PIN.
  • Submit online or mail the signed postcard form.

You Might Also Like

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy.