Progressive Total Loss Insurance Claim Settlement: Who Qualifies?

You qualify if you are a Colorado resident with a first-party claim on your own Progressive policy. Your claim must fit the date window for Progressive Direct or Progressive Preferred and used a Mitchell valuation with a projected sold adjustment. A total loss means Progressive decides your car cannot be repaired or repairs cost more than its value. The settlement addresses one valuation discount, not the total-loss decision itself.

Table of Contents

How does Progressive decide a total loss?

Progressive declares a car a total loss when repairs cost more than its value or it cannot be repaired. An inspection decides the outcome and also considers state percentage thresholds. Progressive explains this process in its total-loss guide.

For a totaled car on your own policy, Progressive pays actual cash value minus your deductible. Actual cash value means market value before the damage. Collision covers crash damage, while comprehensive covers fire, theft, weather, animal strikes and other non-crash causes.

Which policies and dates qualify?

Only two groups qualify, and both need the same valuation flag. Value Pilot, summarizing the court notice in Curran v. Progressive No.

1:22-cv-00878, lists the groups in its Colorado settlement summary. Check your valuation paperwork for a Mitchell report and a line for projected sold adjustment. If that line is missing, you do not fit this settlement.

  • Progressive Direct: Colorado resident, first-party claim submitted April 12, 2019 through July 8, 2026, paid with Mitchell valuation using a projected sold adjustment.
  • Progressive Preferred: Colorado resident, first-party claim submitted Dec. 19, 2021 through July 8, 2026, with the same Mitchell adjustment.

How much will you receive?

Value Pilot's summary of the court notice puts each payment at 68% of the defined adjustment impact. That equals 2.75% of recorded actual cash value for Progressive Direct and 2.25% for Progressive Preferred.

On a $20,000 car, that is about $374 for Direct and about $306 for Preferred. Your check rises or falls with your car's recorded value.

How do you file on time?

File online at COTotalLossClaim.com or mail the postcard form by Feb. 5, 2027.

Use the Claimant ID and PIN from your mailed notice. OpenClassActions reports the filing process in its Curran filing guide.

  • Find your Claimant ID and PIN on the mailed notice.
  • Submit online or mail the postcard form.
  • File by Feb. 5, 2027, even though final court approval was still pending with a hearing set for Jan. 6, 2027.

What is excluded?

The settlement covers only claims on your own Colorado Progressive policy. It excludes claims made against another driver's Progressive policy, according to Value Pilot.

Progressive does not sell traditional gap insurance but offers Loan/Lease Payoff for the loan balance above actual cash value. Progressive caps that benefit at no more than 25% of vehicle value, with exact limits varying by state, as described in its gap insurance explainer.


You Might Also Like

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy.