A class action over a beverage ingredient claim is usually triggered by a mismatch between a front-label promise and a specific ingredient on the back — most often a synthetic acidulant like manufactured citric acid or DL-malic acid sitting behind words like "All Natural" or "Nothing Artificial." The second common trigger is a functional-benefit claim, where the label advertises a health effect that the actual quantity of the active ingredient allegedly cannot deliver. These cases proceed under state consumer-protection laws rather than federal food law, and that distinction is the whole engine. Because the federal government has never defined the key marketing words, there is no federal standard for a defendant to hide behind, and a single ingredient line can support a nationwide claim.
Official resources:
- Read the official guidance from FDA — Use this primary source to verify the official guidance.
- Read the official notice from Natlawreview — Use this primary source to verify the official announcement.
Table of Contents
- Why "Natural" Is the Most Litigated Word on a Can
- The Dual-Function Ingredient That Starts Most Filings
- What Happened in the Ginger Ale Case
- Benefit Claims and the Poppi Settlement
- Why the Same Ingredient Wins in One Court and Loses in Another
- Checking Whether a Beverage You Bought Fits the Pattern
- Frequently Asked Questions
Why "Natural" Is the Most Litigated Word on a Can
The Food and Drug Administration has never issued a regulatory definition of "natural" for food or beverage labels. According to the FDA's own guidance on the term, the agency operates only an informal policy: it will not object to "natural" where nothing artificial or synthetic — including added color regardless of source, artificial flavors, or synthetic substances — has been added to a food that would not normally contain it. That is a non-objection policy, not a rule.
The agency asked for public comment on defining the word after receiving three citizen petitions seeking a definition and one seeking an outright ban; as a Crowell & Moring client alert describes, that comment period closed on May 10, 2016 and produced no regulation. The practical result is that defendants cannot argue federal preemption — the doctrine that a federal standard overrides a state-law claim — because there is no federal standard. Courts routinely reject the defense on exactly that ground, which is why state consumer-protection suits over the word keep reaching discovery.
The Dual-Function Ingredient That Starts Most Filings
The ingredient at the center of these cases is typically one that does two jobs at once. Citric acid and malic acid act as preservatives and as flavoring agents, and the flavor-declaration rules at 21 C.F.R. § 101.22(i) can require a disclosure that a front-of-pack "natural" claim directly contradicts. As commentary from the Food Law Firm frames it, it is the dual-function ingredient — not the marketing word in isolation — that creates the filing. Malic acid shows how precise the pleading gets.
In the Trammell v. Albertsons complaint filed in 2024, plaintiffs allege that DL-malic acid is petrochemically derived and therefore an artificial flavoring under FDA rules, citing 21 C.F.R. § 184.1069(a). The complaint adds a second layer: listing the ingredient as plain "malic acid" rather than "DL-malic acid" compounds the deception behind a "naturally flavored" front label. Citric acid follows the same pattern. Most commercial citric acid is manufactured by fermentation rather than extracted from citrus, and that manufacturing step is what plaintiffs point to when a label promises nothing artificial.
What Happened in the Ginger Ale Case
In October 2026, a federal court in the Southern District of California denied a beverage maker's motion to dismiss a putative class action over "All Natural" and "Nothing Artificial" ginger ale labels on a product containing manufactured citric acid. Crosner Legal's report on the order describes the court treating consumer deception as a jury question. That phrase carries the weight.
Treating deception as a jury question means the judge declined to decide, as a matter of law, that a reasonable consumer could not have been misled. The case moves into discovery, where the cost and exposure for the defendant rise sharply — which is the stage at which many of these matters settle. For a reader tracking these filings, a denied motion to dismiss is the moment a case becomes real. It does not establish that the label was deceptive, and no liability has been found.
Benefit Claims and the Poppi Settlement
The second trigger involves quantity rather than origin. Here the ingredient is genuinely present, but plaintiffs allege the amount is too small to produce the advertised effect. The clearest recent example involves prebiotic soda.
A California federal court granted final approval on April 14, 2026 to an $8.9 million settlement by VNGR Beverage LLC, the maker of Poppi, over allegations that its "gut healthy" marketing overstated the benefit of roughly two grams of prebiotic fiber per can. Chron's report on the approval notes the settlement carried no admission of liability — the standard structure, in which a company resolves claims without conceding the marketing was false. The lesson for label-reading is specific: a functional claim invites scrutiny of the dose, not just the ingredient list. Advertising a physiological outcome sets a bar the quantity has to clear.
Why the Same Ingredient Wins in One Court and Loses in Another
Outcomes are not uniform, and this is the real limitation on any prediction. Courts have dismissed "all natural" beverage suits where the phrase was found ambiguous and the ingredient list dispelled any confusion — including a 2026 Snapple ruling in New York covered by the National Law Review. The same ingredient can survive dismissal in one district and fail in another. The volume is substantial enough that the split matters.
Perkins Coie counted 256 class actions filed against food and beverage companies in 2024 — up 58% from 187 in 2023, and the most in any year since it began tracking in 2008 — and reports more than 200 consumer packaged goods filings in 2025, per its Food & CPG Legal Trends report. Regulatory shifts narrow exposure without closing it. On February 5, 2026 the FDA announced it does not intend to take enforcement action against "no artificial colors" claims on foods containing no certified color additives. Cooley's February 24, 2026 analysis notes this strengthens defendants' arguments but does not stop a consumer from filing a state-law class action.
Checking Whether a Beverage You Bought Fits the Pattern
These are the signals that distinguish a label with litigation exposure from one that simply makes a marketing claim: Two practical cautions. Keep proof of purchase — receipts, order confirmations, loyalty-account history — because a settlement's higher payment tier almost always requires it, while a no-proof tier caps recovery at a small fixed amount. And a case surviving a motion to dismiss is not a settlement; the ginger ale matter is at the start of discovery, not distributing money.
- A front label says "All Natural," "Nothing Artificial," or "Naturally Flavored" while the ingredient list includes citric acid, malic acid, or another acidulant.
- An ingredient appears under a shortened name — "malic acid" where the synthetic form is DL-malic acid.
- The label advertises a bodily effect (gut health, immunity, energy) and the nutrition panel shows a small quantity of the active ingredient.
- The product was bought within the class period a complaint defines, which is typically four years in California and varies by state.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the FDA have a legal definition of "natural" I can point to?
No. The agency has only an informal non-objection policy, and its 2015 request for comment on defining the term closed in May 2016 without producing a rule. That absence is what keeps state-law claims alive.
Is citric acid artificial?
Plaintiffs allege that commercially manufactured citric acid is synthetic rather than citrus-derived, and that this contradicts a "nothing artificial" claim. Courts have not settled the question uniformly — the October 2026 ginger ale ruling sent it to a jury rather than deciding it.
Can I still file if the FDA says a claim is acceptable?
Yes. FDA enforcement discretion governs what the agency will do, not what a consumer may allege under state consumer-protection law. Commentators on the February 2026 color-claim policy made this point directly.
Why do so many of these suits get filed in California?
California's Unfair Competition Law and Consumers Legal Remedies Act give consumers broad standing and a four-year window, and both the ginger ale ruling and the Poppi settlement came out of California federal courts.