On Oct. 23, 2026, the Fifth District ruled an aggrieved employee can bring a headless PAGA suit with only non-individual claims for coworkers. That ruling deepened a split because the Second District bars headless suits in Leeper v. Shipt and Williams.
According to CDF Labor Law LLP, the decision holds the representative-only case can stay in court Fifth District analysis. PAGA is California's Private Attorneys General Act. It lets an aggrieved worker seek civil penalties for Labor Code violations on behalf of the state and other employees. Castillo matters to workers who signed arbitration agreements with class waivers and to employers facing pending PAGA notices.
Table of Contents
- What Makes Castillo Headless?
- Why Did the Court Allow a Representative-Only Suit?
- Where Is the Split Between Courts?
- What Should Workers Do While the Split Is Unresolved?
What Makes Castillo Headless?
The plaintiff was a former service technician. As reported by Proskauer Rose, he signed an onboarding arbitration agreement with a class and collective waiver. He then filed a single-count PAGA suit expressly seeking only non-individual penalties for other employees.
The trial court in Stanislaus County denied the employer's motion to compel arbitration. As reported by Seyfarth Shaw, the Fifth District affirmed because there was nothing arbitrable. Non-individual PAGA claims cannot be forced into arbitration.
Why Did the Court Allow a Representative-Only Suit?
The court focused on Labor Code Section 2699(a). As reported by Seyfarth Shaw, it called the phrase on behalf of the employee and other employees ambiguous. It read and as and-or to permit a representative-only action.
The court also addressed amended Section 2699(c)(1). As reported by Proskauer Rose, it held the requirement that a plaintiff personally suffered each alleged violation decides who qualifies as aggrieved. It does not decide which individual claims must be pled.
Where Is the Split Between Courts?
Castillo followed the Fifth District's 2025 decision in CRST Expedited v. Superior Court. As Proskauer Rose explains, it expressly declined to follow Leeper and Williams California employment law update.
Those Second District cases bar headless suits. The timing widens the effect. Unlike earlier cases under pre-reform law, Castillo applies PAGA as amended effective July 1, 2024. That version governs most current notices and pending cases.
What Should Workers Do While the Split Is Unresolved?
The California Supreme Court granted review of Leeper on its own motion in April 2025. According to Wage Counsel Group, it heard argument Nov. 3, 2026, and must decide by about Feb.
1, 2027 employer briefing on headless PAGA review. That decision will finally resolve the split. Until then, workers with possible claims can protect their options:.
- Check whether your PAGA notice arose under the post-July 1, 2024 rules.
- Keep your onboarding papers, arbitration agreement, pay stubs, and schedules.
- Note filing deadlines and whether your suit seeks individual, non-individual, or both types of penalties.
- Ask an employment lawyer how your district handles headless claims and arbitration motions. Bring your arbitration agreement and notice letter to that first review.