Massachusetts Class Actions Over AI Job Screening Reach Appellate Court

Massachusetts class actions over AI job screening have reached the First Circuit Court of Appeals. The lead case challenges JPMorgan Chase over HireVue video interviews scored by software. Plaintiffs describe these tools as recording answers and scoring language, tone and facial cues into employability scores. The fight centers on whether that scoring counts as a lie-detector test under state law.

Table of Contents

What does Massachusetts law prohibit?

The Massachusetts Legislature defines lie-detector test broadly in the current statute. It covers any polygraph or other device, mechanism, instrument or written examination used to detect deception or verify truthfulness. It bars use as an employment condition and requires a conspicuous application notice.

Plaintiffs now allege video hiring tools function as de facto lie detectors. They point to software that records answers and scores language, tone and facial cues into competency scores. Fisher Phillips reports suits against retailers, beverage, defense and hospitality employers, with several cases still pending.

How did the JPMorgan case reach appeal?

BankingNewsAI reports job applicant Mozart Saint Cyr filed a proposed class action in Suffolk County Superior Court on April 28, 2025. He alleged HireVue AI video interviews were an unlawful lie-detector test and lacked required notice. Fisher Phillips reports the federal judge dismissed that lie-detector claim on Oct. 22, 2025, calling the deception-purpose allegations wholly conclusory in its case analysis.

BankingNewsAI notes the same order remanded only the standalone application-notice claim to state court. The court held the missing notice was a purely informational injury without federal standing. First Things First lists the appeal as First Circuit No. 25-2129, filed Nov. 25, 2025.

What happened at the First Circuit?

First Things First listed Mozart Saint Cyr v. JPMorgan Chase for the July 28, 2026 Boston sitting before Judges Gelpí, Thompson and Dunlap. Each side received 15 minutes for argument. Law360, via the BankingNewsAI case chronology, said the panel appeared doubtful AI screening qualifies as a barred test in the case chronology.

The same chronology reports no appellate decision had published as of Oct. 21, 2026. HireVue and Fisher Phillips materials stress no court has found JPMorgan used HireVue to assess honesty. Employers are still urged to document a non-deception purpose for video analytics.

Can applicants file a claim now?

Fisher Phillips describes Baker v. CVS over HireVue assessments as an earlier copycat case. Fisher Phillips says the case survived dismissal in February 2024 and settled in July 2024, triggering a wave of suits in its 2025 review.

If you had a recorded video interview in Massachusetts, preserve your own file before any deadline appears. A complete file helps you compare what happened against the two legal theories in Saint Cyr. Do not assume every video interview qualifies under the statute. Fisher Phillips notes violations carry criminal penalties plus at least $500 per violation and attorney's fees.

  • Save the application, interview invitation and any notice screens
  • Note whether the application showed the Section 19B lie-detector notice
  • Watch the remanded notice claim and First Circuit docket for orders

You Might Also Like

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy.